The CPAP Case: Navigating the Recall, Health Risks, and Legal Options

Last updated Tuesday, January 30th, 2024

The CPAP Case: Navigating the Recall, Health Risks, and Legal Options

Are you grappling with the Philips CPAP case and its recall implications? Understand the potential health risks, navigate your legal options, and learn how to pursue compensation with our focused guide. With no fluff, this article delivers straight answers to safeguard your health and legal rights.

Key Takeaways

    • The recalled Philips CPAP, BiPAP, and ventilator devices pose serious health risks due to the breakdown of PE-PUR foam, leading to the release of toxic particles and gases that can cause symptoms like dizziness and headache or serious conditions such as cancer and lung disease.
    • Compensation claims against Philips are available to eligible individuals affected by the CPAP recall, with options including class actions, individual lawsuits, and multidistrict litigation, potentially covering both economic and non-economic damages incurred by victims.
    • The FDA plays a critical role in managing the CPAP recall by issuing safety communications, requiring Philips to provide solutions for affected consumers, and ensuring ongoing investigations into the health risks posed by the defective devices.

Have You Had Complications From Your CPAP Machine?

Find Out What Your Case is Worth From an Experienced Mass Tort Attorney.

Exploring the Philips CPAP Recall: A Comprehensive Overview

The healthcare sector was profoundly impacted by the recall of the Philips CPAP machine. The culprit, PE-PUR foam, used for noise reduction, had the potential to break down and release harmful particles into the device’s air pathway. This posed a significant health risk to users of the CPAP sleep apnea machine, leading to Philips issuing a recall for its CPAP, BiPAP, and ventilator devices, including popular models like DreamStation, SystemOne, and Trilogy. With Philips CPAP machines recalled, patients and healthcare providers alike were left seeking alternative solutions for sleep apnea treatment.

As if this wasn’t enough, Philips also issued a separate recall for certain Philips Respironics ventilators, including the Trilogy EVO Ventilators, in December 2021 and had to notify users of the recall’s health risks. This marked the beginning of a series of repercussions that have since unfolded.

Health Implications of Recalled Philips CPAP Machines

Significant health implications arise from the deteriorating PE-PUR foam in Philips CPAP machines. When degraded, the foam releases particles and toxic gases into the air pathway, which patients may inhale or ingest. This exposure can cause immediate symptoms such as dizziness, headache, vomiting, nausea, and respiratory tract irritation. It can also lead to serious health risks like irritation to the skin, eyes, nose, respiratory tract, and even toxicity or cancer-causing effects to organs. The severity of the health risks has led to the submission of over 105,000 medical device reports to the FDA, including 385 of them involving deaths.

Let’s delve deeper into two significant health implications: lung cancer and Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD).

Lung Cancer Risks from Faulty CPAP Devices

It is alarming to note the link between lung cancer and faulty CPAP devices. Symptoms of lung cancer, such as respiratory issues, align with those reported by users of the recalled Philips CPAP machines. But the risk doesn’t end there. Lung cancer due to the recalled devices can also lead to laryngeal cancer, bringing additional symptoms unique to this type of cancer, including changes in voice and a persistent sore throat.

The correlation between exposure to the degraded CPAP foam and the development of lung cancer has become a significant concern. As users continue to inhale the toxic particles and gases released by the degrading foam, the risk of developing lung cancer increases dramatically, creating an urgent need to address this issue.

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) and CPAP Usage

For COPD patients, CPAP therapy can be both a remedy and a risk. On one hand, CPAP therapy can improve respiratory mechanics in stable COPD patients by affecting respiratory patterns, reducing airway resistance, and lowering inspiratory threshold load. On the other hand, high levels of CPAP can cause dynamic pulmonary hyperinflation, which negatively impacts diaphragmatic function and can exacerbate existing COPD symptoms.

Hence, while continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) usage can lead to improvements in breathing pattern and reduced work of breathing, thereby enhancing neural respiratory drive efficiency, it’s crucial to remember that the benefits are counterbalanced by the risk of increasing dynamic pulmonary hyperinflation, which could worsen patient outcomes. This calls for further investigation on the overall effects of CPAP on respiratory mechanics in COPD patients without respiratory failure.

Legal Rights for CPAP Machine Users

Numerous lawsuits against Philips have stemmed from the serious health implications of the recalled CPAP machines. As a victim, you may be entitled to claim compensation for the financial damages related to the Philips CPAP recall lawsuit. For instance, Philips Respironics agreed to a partial settlement of $479 million to compensate individuals for such damages.

The compensation can cover medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering. To understand better how to initiate a lawsuit and the eligibility criteria, let’s delve deeper.

Initiating a CPAP Recall Lawsuit

Female lawyer smilingThough initiating a CPAP recall lawsuit may seem intimidating, it is a vital move in defending your rights. To kick start a class action lawsuit, you or a small group of plaintiffs must:

  1. File a suit and request the court to grant class certification.
  2. Prove the presence of numerous victims.
  3. Identify common issues.
  4. Demonstrate that the lead plaintiff(s) can adequately represent the whole class.

However, class actions aren’t the only option. Individual lawsuits may be more appropriate to seek adequate compensation for serious injuries or illnesses caused by recalled Philips CPAP machines. Moreover, mass tort lawsuits offer an alternative for those affected by the CPAP machine recall. In such cases, consulting an attorney experienced in mass torts and medical device litigation is advised.

Eligibility Criteria for Joining a CPAP Lawsuit

When pursuing legal recourse, considering eligibility to join a lawsuit is critical. Individuals who purchased or used one of the recalled Philips CPAP, BiPAP, or ventilator devices and have experienced adverse health effects may qualify to join a lawsuit. An attorney can assess your case’s alignment with existing cases, explain the statute of limitations, and discuss the available legal options.

However, it’s important to remember that not everyone may qualify for a mass tort lawsuit. For instance, if you used a non-recalled machine or experienced health effects that differ from others in the lawsuit, you may not qualify. Alternatively, if your case warrants greater compensation, other legal avenues may be more appropriate.

Multidistrict litigation (MDL) offers an alternative to class actions for CPAP lawsuits, allowing individual plaintiffs to retain more control over their case and the possibility for individualized settlements.

Understanding CPAP Recall Compensation

Grasping the compensation involved in a CPAP recall lawsuit is crucial. Victims may be entitled to claim both economic and non-economic damages. When the CPAP device was recalled, it led to illness or injury and the economic damages refers to the tangible, financial losses suffered as a result. Non-economic damages, on the other hand, include compensation for intangible losses such as pain and suffering, mental anguish, and loss of enjoyment in life.

The amount of non-economic damages can often be calculated by:

  • Multiplying economic damages by a factor based on the injury’s severity and permanence
  • Considering state laws and whether the plaintiff has any fault in their injuries
  • Awarding punitive damages to punish egregious conduct and gross negligence, potentially leading to sums greater than compensatory damages

Therefore, selecting a CPAP recall attorney is crucial as they can provide a clear understanding of the damages eligible for recovery and help estimate potential settlements.

Choosing the Right CPAP Recall Attorney

Selecting an appropriate attorney is a significant stride in your quest for justice. An experienced Philips CPAP recall attorney with a proven track record in personal injury and product liability lawsuits, including Philips CPAP cancer lawyers, can guide you through the complex legal landscape. It’s crucial to choose a lawyer who exhibits understanding and empathy towards your situation, supporting your physical and emotional recovery throughout the process.

Your attorney should be adept at:

  • Gathering necessary evidence, such as medical records and the CPAP device itself, to build a strong case linking symptoms to the use of defective Philips products
  • Being knowledgeable about legal and financial aspects, such as contingency fees, statutes of limitations, and accurately valuing your claim
  • Communicating clearly about the litigation process, managing your expectations, and being committed to withstanding lengthy legal battles

The Role of FDA Safety Communication in CPAP Recalls

In the Philips CPAP recall saga, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) plays a central role. Regularly updating safety communications, the FDA informs the public about new findings and health risks associated with the PE-PUR foam used in Philips CPAP machines. These communications have been vital in shedding light on the scope of the problem, with the FDA collecting over 105,000 medical device reports, including 385 reports of death, possibly related to the breakdown of PE-PUR foam.

The FDA’s role in the CPAP recall includes:

  • Providing guidance on how to handle the recall, including registering affected devices and reporting problems through the MedWatch Voluntary Reporting Form
  • Requiring Philips to submit a plan for repair, replacement, or refund of the recalled devices
  • Requiring Philips to engage an independent laboratory for additional testing of safety risks

The FDA’s involvement is instrumental in ensuring that Philips addresses the potential health risks posed by the silicone foam used in reworked ventilators.

Replacing Your Recalled CPAP Device

Especially when the device in question is integral to your health, the news of a recall can be distressing. But don’t worry. After determining that your CPAP device is part of the recall, you can register it on the Philips website or contact Philips for registration assistance. Keep a record of the registration confirmation number and device serial number, which Philips will require for future communications regarding your replacement device.

Discuss with your healthcare provider the best course of action, which may include stop using your device, use alternative treatments, or continue using your device while waiting for a replacement or repair. Upon receiving a replacement, follow Philips instructions for returning your recalled device and update your registration with additional information to be considered for prioritized replacement if needed. In case of any delays in receiving your replacement device after registration, Philips may require additional information or consent, which you can provide through their Patient Portal or by calling their support number.

FAQs About Philips Respironics Ventilators and BiPAP Machines

Considering the extensive scale of the Philips CPAP recall, having questions is only natural. Here are some frequently asked questions to provide you with more information.

  1. Are there alternatives to Philips Respironics machines due to the recall? Yes, patients seeking alternatives can consider CPAP machines from other brands, such as ResMed AirSense 10, Z2 Auto Travel CPAP Machine, and F&P SleepStyle Auto CPAP.
  2. What are the alternative PAP machines? Other PAP machines include BiPAP, APAP (Auto-Adjusting Positive Airway Pressure), EPAP (Expiratory Positive Airway Pressure), and ASV (adaptive-servo ventilation) devices, offering varying functions for different needs.
  3. Are there non-invasive CPAP alternatives? Yes. Non-invasive CPAP alternatives include oral appliances like mandibular repositioning devices, tongue-retaining devices, and lifestyle changes such as avoiding alcohol, smoking, and maintaining a healthy diet and exercise routine.
  4. Are there surgical options for sleep apnea treatment? Yes. Surgical options include procedures like mandibular/maxillary advancement surgery. Hypoglossal nerve stimulation is a procedural alternative to CPAP therapy.
  5. How should CPAP machines be cleaned? CPAP machines should be cleaned with distilled water or a mild detergent for various parts, vinegar for sanitizing the humidifier, and allowed to air dry without exposure to sunlight.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a CPAP count as a personal item when flying?

Yes, a CPAP machine does not count as a personal item when flying, and it can be carried onto the plane as an additional item allowed for medical devices.

Do I have to take my CPAP out for TSA?

Yes, you need to take your CPAP machine out of its carrying case for TSA screening, but the tubing, power cord, and masks can stay in the case. This is in accordance with TSA regulations.

Is there a lawsuit against ResMed CPAP?

Yes, there is a lawsuit against ResMed CPAP, which was filed in 2016 in a federal district court in Columbia, SC, and involved allegations investigated by the federal government.

Can I use bottled water in my CPAP for one night?

Yes, you can use bottled water in your CPAP humidifier for one night, as long as it is distilled water to avoid mineral buildup. Using purified or spring water may cause residue and damage over time.

Which CPAP devices have been recalled?

The US Food and Drug Administration safety communication on provides information on CPAP devices that have been recalled.

Hurt In An Accident? Review Your Case, For FREE

We want to help you get through one of the most stressful experiences you can have. Tell us about your car accident and one of our Personal Injury Lawyers will review it, for free, within one business day.
Member, State Bar of GeorgiaAvvo Clients Choice Award - Murphy Law Firm

Satisfaction Guaranteed

If you are NOT 100% SATISFIED with our services, you can fire our firm within the 30-day period of hiring us and NOT OWE US ONE PENNY!

James Murphy

Book Your Free Consultation with Georgia’s Top Award Winning Attorney Now.

Call 770-577-3020

Murphy Law Firm featured on NBC
Murphy Law Firm featured on CBS
Murphy Law Firm featured on CNN
James Murphy - seen on ABC
Murphy Law Firm featured on FOX
Murphy Law Firm featured on MSNBC
Murphy Law Firm featured on Fox News
Murphy Law Firm featured on CNBC
Murphy Law featured in USA Today
Murphy Law Firm featured in The Wall Street Journal
Murphy Law Firm featured in Forbes
Murphy Law Firm - seen in Newsweek