Do I Qualify for Hernia Mesh Lawsuit? Essential Criteria for Claimants

Last updated Tuesday, January 30th, 2024

Do I Qualify for Hernia Mesh Lawsuit? Essential Criteria for Claimants

If you’re experiencing complications after hernia mesh surgery, you may be considering legal action and asking yourself, “do I qualify for hernia mesh lawsuit?” Qualifying for a lawsuit hinges on specific criteria: identifying the hernia mesh used in your surgery, linking your health complications directly to the mesh, and taking action within the legal time frame set by statutes of limitations. In this article, we’ll walk you through the necessary steps to determine your eligibility for a “do I qualify for hernia mesh lawsuit,” helping you understand the process and empowering you to seek justice.

Key Takeaways

    • Hernia mesh litigation targets manufacturers due to complications from mesh use, with over 24,800 pending lawsuits suggesting widespread issues involving mesh failure, infection, chronic pain, adhesion, bowel obstruction, mesh migration, and organ perforation.
    • Qualifying for a hernia mesh lawsuit requires identifying the specific mesh used, linking complications to mesh failure, and filing within the applicable statute of limitations, which generally starts a year or two after the injury is recognized.
    • The hernia mesh lawsuit process involves initial consultations with specialized lawyers, collecting relevant medical records and evidence, and filing the lawsuit potentially as part of a multi-district litigation (MDL) for efficiency, with compensation amounts varying based on the severity of injuries and the impact on the victim’s life.

Have You Had Complications From a Hernia Mesh?

Find Out What Your Case is Worth From an Experienced Mass Tort Attorney.

Understanding Hernia Mesh Litigation

Hernia mesh litigation is the legal action taken against hernia mesh product manufacturers, due to complications and side effects caused by mesh use. These lawsuits are not isolated cases. As of January 2024, there are over 24,800 pending hernia mesh lawsuits across multiple MDLs, indicating a potential hernia mesh class action. It’s a staggering number, but what triggers the initiation of such lawsuits?

Some common triggers for hernia mesh lawsuits include:

  • Mesh failure or erosion
  • Infection
  • Chronic pain
  • Adhesion
  • Bowel obstruction
  • Mesh migration
  • Organ perforation

If you have experienced any of these complications after undergoing hernia mesh surgery, it may be worth consulting with a lawyer to explore your legal options.

Usually, triggers for these lawsuits include defective design, manufacturing flaws, failure to warn, and severe injuries from hernia mesh complications. These injuries can range from pain, surgical site infection, hernia recurrence, adhesion, bladder injuries, vascular injuries, to mesh failure and punctured organs. The consequences can be significantly detrimental to the victims’ quality of life, hence the pursuit of legal action.

But who is usually at the receiving end of these lawsuits? Manufacturers like:

  • Ethicon (a Johnson & Johnson subsidiary)
  • Bard/Davol
  • Atrium Medical
  • Covidien

These hernia mesh manufacturers, producing both hernia mesh implants and surgical mesh, are among those commonly targeted in hernia mesh litigation. They have faced thousands of lawsuits due to the injuries caused by their defective hernia mesh devices.

Eligibility Requirements for Hernia Mesh Lawsuits

Not all cases of hernia mesh complications automatically qualify for a lawsuit. There are specific eligibility requirements that need to be met. This includes:

  • Identifying the type of hernia mesh used in your surgery
  • Linking the complications you experienced to a failure of the mesh
  • Complying with the statute of limitations.

Identifying Defective Hernia Mesh Devices

Symptoms like infection, chronic pain, torn or broken mesh, mesh migration, adhesion, and hernia recurrence can indicate defective hernia mesh devices, including hernia mesh implant. These symptoms can serve as early warnings of potential complications and are crucial in building a strong hernia mesh lawsuit.

But how do you determine the specific hernia mesh device used in your surgery? One way is to contact the surgeon or hospital where the surgery was performed to determine the make and model of the hernia mesh used. This information can be crucial in establishing the link between the hernia mesh and your complications.

Actually, by contacting the medical records department of the hospital where your surgery was performed, you can determine the specific hernia mesh device used. The operative note and other pertinent surgical records should contain details regarding the particular brand and model of hernia mesh that was implanted.

Knowing the specific hernia mesh device used in your surgery not only helps in identifying potential defects but also serves as a strong starting point for your hernia mesh lawsuit.

Linking Complications to Mesh Failure

After identifying the specific hernia mesh device used in your surgery, you should then associate the complications you’ve experienced with mesh failure. This is a critical factor in determining your eligibility for a lawsuit. The most frequent complications associated with faulty hernia mesh devices include:

  • Persistent pain
  • Infection
  • Hernia recurrence
  • Adhesion
  • Bowel obstruction
  • Migration
  • Shrinkage

Man standing in HospitalMedical professionals can establish a link between complications and mesh failure by identifying common issues and examining specific issues related to the type of mesh used, like torn or broken mesh. The required evidence may include:

  • Poor surgical technique
  • Lack of surgical experience
  • Improper product labeling
  • Medical malpractice
  • Failure to warn about risks
  • Evidence of higher risk of failure or complications such as infection and hernia recurrence.

It is also recommended for patients to:

  • Have their doctor assess the mesh failure and meticulously record all treatments received
  • Preserve the failed mesh if removed for evidential purposes
  • Gather all pertinent medical records, including the specific type of hernia mesh utilized

This is crucial for effectively documenting the complications.

An illustration of a successful hernia mesh lawsuit is the lawsuit involving Jacob Bryan, a resident of Florida, who encountered complications with the Bard 3DMax hernia mesh, and the complications were evidently linked to the mesh failure. This case serves as a strong example of how linking complications to mesh failure can lead to a successful hernia mesh trial.

Timing Matters: Statute of Limitations

Another significant consideration is when you file your hernia mesh lawsuit. The statute of limitations for hernia mesh lawsuits generally commences within a year or two after the victims become aware of their injuries. This means you have a limited window of time to file your lawsuit after you’ve recognized the injuries caused by the hernia mesh.

Individuals typically have a window of 1 to 6 years from the date of their injury to pursue compensation from the responsible manufacturer for a defective hernia mesh claim. This window can vary greatly depending on your state.

In medical device lawsuits such as hernia mesh, the statute of limitations usually falls within six years of the date of injury, similar to other personal injury lawsuits. It’s crucial to consult with an experienced hernia mesh lawyer to understand the specific statute of limitations in your state.

If the statute of limitations has expired for a hernia mesh lawsuit, it can severely limit your legal options. Failing to file within this period can render an otherwise valid claim baseless. Therefore, it’s crucial to act swiftly once you’ve recognized the injuries caused by the hernia mesh.

Steps to Initiate a Hernia Mesh Claim

After ascertaining your eligibility for a hernia mesh lawsuit, you can start your claim. This involves a series of steps, starting with a consultation with a hernia mesh lawyer, followed by collecting medical records and evidence, and finally filing the lawsuit.

Initial Consultation with Hernia Mesh Lawyers

Initiating your hernia mesh claim begins with a consultation with a hernia mesh lawyer. This initial consultation is crucial as it helps determine the validity of your case and the best course of action. During this consultation, you can expect a discussion about your case, an overview of the lawyer’s experience in handling similar cases, and a potential review of your medical records.

When selecting a lawyer for your hernia mesh claim, there are key factors to consider. It is important to choose a lawyer with:

  • Relevant experience in handling similar cases
  • A deep understanding of related medical concepts
  • Operates on a contingency fee basis, meaning they receive payment only if your case is successful

During the initial consultation, it is advisable to inquire about the following:

  • The lawyer’s experience with hernia mesh lawsuits
  • Their success rate
  • Potential compensation
  • The timeline of the legal process
  • Any alternative options or treatments available

This information will give you a clear understanding of what to expect moving forward.

Finally, the hernia mesh lawyer will evaluate the viability of your claim. This evaluation is based on whether the injuries were a result of hernia surgery and by evaluating the associated side effects.

Collecting Medical Records and Evidence

Following the initial consultation, you should gather all relevant medical records and evidence to back up your hernia mesh claim. This includes:

  • All medical records concerning your hernia mesh surgery
  • Specifics about the hernia mesh product utilized
  • Any documentation acquired during the surgery such as brochures and consent forms
  • All relevant medical expenses
  • Expert witness reports

To acquire your medical records, you may request copies from your healthcare provider either in person or through their online portal. For gathering supplementary evidence, it is advisable to compile all pertinent documents related to the hernia mesh, such as details of the mesh type and any associated complications, and seek expert opinions.

Additionally, a hernia mesh lawyer can aid in obtaining your medical records and assembling your evidence dossier, as well as preparing for the discovery process. This assistance can be instrumental in ensuring that all necessary evidence is collected and presented effectively.

Medical records play a crucial role in substantiating the eligibility for a hernia mesh lawsuit. They serve as substantiating evidence to establish a correlation between complications and the hernia mesh, thereby significantly contributing to the determination of qualification for compensation and the estimation of the claim’s value.

Filing the Hernia Mesh Lawsuit

After all necessary evidence has been collected, you can proceed to file the hernia mesh lawsuit. This involves:

  1. Filing the necessary claim
  2. Participating in the discovery process
  3. Presenting pre-trial motions
  4. Reaching a settlement, if the case does not proceed to trial

Individual product liability personal injury lawsuits are filed for hernia mesh cases. These cases are handled separately and involve the liability of the product. The specific time limit for filing the claim is determined by state law, typically within one to two years.

In order to proceed with a hernia mesh lawsuit, it is generally essential to collect various documents including:

  • Medical bills
  • Medical records
  • Expert witness reports
  • Financial information
  • Documentation pertaining to the surgery such as brochures, medical records, and consent forms.

The process for filing a hernia mesh lawsuit typically spans over several years before a hernia mesh settlement is reached or a resolution is made with the mesh manufacturer. However, many cases settle before going to trial, offering a faster route to financial recovery for plaintiffs.

A hernia mesh lawsuit can be filed against the manufacturer of the defective hernia mesh or the surgeon who performed the procedure. It’s important to consult with your hernia mesh lawyer to determine the best course of action for your specific case.

Compensation in Hernia Mesh Lawsuits

After filing your hernia mesh lawsuit, you might be curious about the potential compensation amount. The amount of compensation in hernia mesh lawsuits depends on a variety of factors including the severity of injuries, medical expenses, and lost wages.

Factors Influencing Settlement Amounts

Lawyers talking in court roomVarious key factors impact the settlement amounts in hernia mesh lawsuits. The primary considerations include the severity of the case and the extent of the injuries, as well as the impact of the injury on the claimant’s quality of life.

The claimant’s future earning potential can also have a significant impact on the settlement amount. Depending on the specifics of each case, compensation for lost wages or diminished earning capacity can range from $500,000 to 1 million.

The age of the claimant can also impact hernia mesh lawsuit settlements. Younger individuals may receive higher compensation due to the longer expected period of impact from the injuries. This is because they have a longer working life ahead of them, and the injuries could potentially affect their ability to earn a living.

Average Hernia Mesh Payout Expectations

So, what payout can you anticipate from a hernia mesh lawsuit? The payout amount is influenced by several factors, including:

  • The defendant being sued
  • The severity of the injuries
  • The number of revision surgeries
  • The impact on the plaintiff’s quality of life
  • The strength of the evidence

On average, the payout in hernia mesh lawsuits is estimated to range from $80,000 to $90,000.

Indeed, the severity of complications from the hernia mesh can have an impact on the payout. Individual plaintiffs in hernia mesh lawsuits who have experienced more severe complications often receive larger settlements. This is due to the increased impact on their health and quality of life..

Yet, it’s important to note that these are just averages and the actual compensation could be much higher or lower depending on the specifics of each case. For example, some plaintiffs have received millions of dollars in compensation.

Therefore, it’s crucial to consult with an experienced hernia mesh attorney who can provide a more accurate estimate based on the specifics of your case.

Recourse for Denied Hernia Mesh Claims

Sometimes, hernia mesh claims might be denied. But a denial doesn’t mean the end of the road. There are several steps you can take to appeal the decision or explore alternative legal avenues.

The initial step to appeal a denial of a hernia mesh claim is to internally appeal within the health insurance provider. If your claim continues to be denied, it is advisable to review the trial for any legal errors and proceed with an appeal based on those grounds. An appeal does not entail a rehearing of the case but rather addresses specific legal errors.

More than 50% of appeals for coverage or reimbursement denials in the medical industry have been successful. This indicates a substantial likelihood of overturning the original decision on appeal.

If an appeal proves unsuccessful, alternative legal options may involve engaging in settlement negotiations with the defendant or initiating a lawsuit against the manufacturer of the hernia mesh.

Furthermore, alternative methods for hernia repair surgery, such as non-mesh repairs utilizing sutures or patches crafted from biological materials, may be explored.

Navigating Multi-District Litigation (MDL)

In certain situations, your hernia mesh lawsuit might be incorporated into a larger multi-district litigation (MDL). MDL in hernia mesh lawsuits involves the consolidation of civil cases related to hernia mesh from various federal districts into a single court to streamline the handling and resolution process.

Individual hernia mesh lawsuits are consolidated into an MDL through a determination made by the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation (JPML). The JPML assesses whether the lawsuits should be consolidated based on substantially similar complaints against an allegedly defective product. If the criteria are met, the lawsuits are consolidated in one court.

MDL facilitates the legal process in hernia mesh lawsuits by:

  • Consolidating multiple federal lawsuits into a single case
  • Enabling one MDL judge to make decisions that are applicable to all the plaintiffs’ matters
  • Preventing inconsistent lower court rulings
  • Expediting the progress of individual actions through the courts in a more efficient and cost-effective manner.

The benefits of MDL in hernia mesh lawsuits include:

  • The ability for injured individuals to initiate individual product liability lawsuits while leveraging shared discovery and experts
  • Gaining from a consistent set of rules and rulings
  • Achieving cost-effectiveness
  • Cases placed under an MDL may be resolved more expeditiously.

Recognizing the Signs of Hernia Mesh Failure

It’s vital to recognize the signs of hernia mesh failure for timely medical attention and possible legal action. The prevalent indicators of hernia mesh failure encompass:

  • Pain and discomfort
  • Nausea
  • Lethargy
  • Constipation or bowel obstruction
  • Erectile dysfunction
  • Hernia recurrence
  • Severe swelling at the surgical site
  • Tenderness or pain
  • Extreme bloating
  • Inability to pass stool

If you experience any of these symptoms, it is important to seek medical attention immediately.

Pain related to hernia mesh failure may manifest as:

  • a burning sensation
  • inflammation and swelling
  • tingling
  • general discomfort
  • sexual discomfort

These symptoms can be alarming and should prompt you to seek medical attention.

Indications of hernia recurrence due to mesh failure may manifest as:

  • The presence of a protrusion at or in close proximity to the initial hernia location
  • Discomfort ranging from mild to intense
  • Mild pain or sensitivity around the surgical area
  • Swelling
  • Nausea

These symptoms could be a clear sign that the hernia mesh has failed and should prompt you to seek medical attention.

Symptoms indicative of hernia mesh failure may manifest within two weeks post-surgery or could potentially arise several years after the procedure. This underscores the importance of regular follow-up appointments after hernia mesh surgery and the need to report any unusual symptoms to your doctor.

Impact of Hernia Mesh Recalls on Lawsuits

Hernia mesh recalls can greatly influence lawsuits. Manufacturers of hernia mesh have recalled over 211,000 units from 2005 to 2019, citing complications such as mesh failure, punctured organs, and hernia recurrence. These recalls can provide additional evidence of device defects and manufacturer negligence.

Manufacturers generally initiate hernia mesh recalls, which are frequently voluntary and not required by the FDA. The documentation provided by manufacturers, detailing the quantity of units recalled and related complications, may indicate negligence if it is established that they were aware of these risks beforehand.

These recalls serve as indicators of product defects, shedding light on the failure rates and injuries linked to the products. If the claimed injuries are linked to a recalled mesh, the compensation amounts may vary, with estimates ranging from approximately $60,000 to $1 million, depending on the severity and impact of complications.

Therefore, hernia mesh recalls can significantly strengthen your case and potentially increase the amount of compensation you receive.

The Role of Hernia Mesh Attorneys in Your Case

Hernia mesh attorneys have a crucial role in guiding claimants through the legal process. They offer personalized care and support to injured clients, conduct a comprehensive investigation of the case, gather essential evidence, obtain medical records, and manage all aspects of the claims process from beginning to end.

Furthermore, hernia mesh attorneys support the rights of their clients by offering legal representation and guidance, as well as:

  • Compiling evidence
  • Interviewing witnesses
  • Consulting with medical experts to construct a robust case
  • Engaging in negotiations with insurance companies and manufacturers to secure equitable compensation for their clients
  • Litigating and presenting the evidence in court in cases where a settlement is not achieved

A hernia mesh attorney must possess the following:

  • Specialized knowledge in hernia mesh lawsuits, including a deep understanding of the medical aspects
  • Extensive experience in medical device litigation
  • Strong communication skills to effectively engage with clients

This expertise can make a significant difference in the outcome of your lawsuit.

Finally, the key duties and obligations of a hernia mesh attorney involve assisting clients in securing equitable compensation for the complications they have endured. Engaging a hernia mesh attorney can therefore be one of the most crucial steps in pursuing a hernia mesh lawsuit.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it too late to file a hernia mesh lawsuit?

It may be too late to file a hernia mesh lawsuit if the incident occurred more than two or three years ago, depending on your state’s statute of limitations.

What is the average settlement for a hernia mesh?

Based on settlements from previous lawsuits, the average settlement for a hernia mesh lawsuit is typically between $40,000 and $60,000.

Has anyone won a hernia mesh lawsuit?

Yes, individuals have won hernia mesh lawsuits, with some receiving financial compensation for damages caused by the defective products. For example, in separate cases, Stinson was awarded $500,000 and Milanesi was awarded $255,000, demonstrating successful legal action against the manufacturers.

What is hernia mesh litigation?

Hernia mesh litigation refers to legal action taken against hernia mesh manufacturers due to complications and side effects from the use of the mesh. It involves pursuing legal recourse for issues arising from the product.

How do I know if I qualify for a hernia mesh lawsuit?

To determine if you qualify for a hernia mesh lawsuit, consider factors such as the type of mesh used, any complications experienced, and the timing of the surgery and discovery of injuries.


Hurt In An Accident? Review Your Case, For FREE

We want to help you get through one of the most stressful experiences you can have. Tell us about your car accident and one of our Personal Injury Lawyers will review it, for free, within one business day.
Member, State Bar of GeorgiaAvvo Clients Choice Award - Murphy Law Firm

Satisfaction Guaranteed

If you are NOT 100% SATISFIED with our services, you can fire our firm within the 30-day period of hiring us and NOT OWE US ONE PENNY!

James Murphy

Book Your Free Consultation with Georgia’s Top Award Winning Attorney Now.

Call 770-577-3020

Murphy Law Firm featured on NBC
Murphy Law Firm featured on CBS
Murphy Law Firm featured on CNN
James Murphy - seen on ABC
Murphy Law Firm featured on FOX
Murphy Law Firm featured on MSNBC
Murphy Law Firm featured on Fox News
Murphy Law Firm featured on CNBC
Murphy Law featured in USA Today
Murphy Law Firm featured in The Wall Street Journal
Murphy Law Firm featured in Forbes
Murphy Law Firm - seen in Newsweek